BIP3 revisions #2037

1. 
   luke-jr commented at 10:00 pm on November 15, 2025: member

   This addresses several issues identified in my review of BIP 3. Other unaddressed issues are being posted to the mailing list for further discussion.
2. bip-0003: Clarify the need for relevance as a standard 23d3417fb4
3. bip-0003: Remove overly broad AI/LLM usage disclosure requirement 092c9a3394
4. bip-0003: Remove assumption Author was involved in writing the original document 8a802cdb30
5. bip-0003: Require the Specification section d12b976ed2
6. bip-0003: Broaden reference implementation format b46e819591
7. bip-0003: Clarify editor assignment of BIP numbers a399d0791d
8. bip-0003: Remove implied requirement for third-party contribution to BIPs 687110fe31
9. bip-0003: Soften the requirement to include test vectors to a recommendation 1e71b24fb1
10. bip-0003: Replace "compliant" with "compatible" c872fc4913
11. bip-0003: Avoid implying BIP editors must reply to every ML post cf1b37cae4
12. bip-0003: Remove assumption authors submitting BIPs also proposed them to the ML themselves b7089a3f1c
13. bip-0003: Move Type header responsibility to the author(s) 953db4fec0
14. bip-0003: Changes from BIP 2: Make it match actual spec 00bef75d20
15. bip-0003: Drop self-contradicting capitalization Rationale 8320119837
16. bip-0003: Better phrasing for Rationale/OtherImplementations c3bc016e6f
17. bip-0003: Explicitly specify preferred method of naming files prior to assignment

    Based-on: aecb84f38daf6c9c3ab5b1e87bddb3a556460812

    ea81a76555
18. luke-jr requested review from murchandamus on Nov 15, 2025
19. luke-jr added the label Proposed BIP modification on Nov 15, 2025

Contributors
luke-jr

Review Requested
murchandamus

Labels
Proposed BIP modification