For transaction f4dedd64c9841d53bbda8beeda52235ec986f1400606812d9c033ac34105532c, the call of [getrawtransaction(verbose)] and [getrawtransaction(hex) + decoderawtransaction] has totally different result,including txid.
Step of reproducing the issue:
- Use getrawtransaction(hex) + decoderawtransaction
0curl --user yourAuth --data-binary '{"jsonrpc": "1.0","id":"curltest","method":"getrawtransaction", "params": ["f4dedd64c9841d53bbda8beeda52235ec986f1400606812d9c033ac34105532c"] }' -H 'content-type: text/plain;' http://yourEndPoint
Returns:
0{
1 "result": "0100000000010115a16270d3ee7ccc58a0757c1d8e1763790f223d4e4c3823948fb3dfdf9865180100000000ffffffff023f3256000000000017a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c8738ee4647000000001600140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe91002473044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb465260121031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c400000000",
2 "error": null,
3 "id": null
4}
Decode with decoderawtransaction:
0curl --user yourAuth --data-binary '{"jsonrpc": "1.0", "id":"curltest", "method": "decoderawtransaction", "params": ["0100000000010115a16270d3ee7ccc58a0757c1d8e1763790f223d4e4c3823948fb3dfdf9865180100000000ffffffff023f3256000000000017a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c8738ee4647000000001600140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe91002473044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb465260121031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c400000000"] }' -H 'content-type: text/plain;' http://yourEndPoint
Returns:
0{
1 "result": {
2 "txid": "0b637b18840d8fc978a657a3422df3c246c86e4c4046d90e63bf0f86b179b403",
3 "hash": "0b637b18840d8fc978a657a3422df3c246c86e4c4046d90e63bf0f86b179b403",
4 "version": 1,
5 "size": 223,
6 "vsize": 223,
7 "locktime": 0,
8 "vin": [
9
10 ],
11 "vout": [
12 {
13 "value": 90023651848.04721921,
14 "n": 0,
15 "scriptPubKey": {
16 "asm": "8 OP_GREATERTHAN OP_DROP OP_SWAP 8e1763790f223d4e4c3823948fb3dfdf9865180100000000ffffffff02 3256000000000017a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c8738ee4647000000001600140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe91002 3044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb4652601 031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c4",
17 "hex": "58a0757c1d8e1763790f223d4e4c3823948fb3dfdf9865180100000000ffffffff023f3256000000000017a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c8738ee4647000000001600140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe91002473044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb465260121031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c4",
18 "type": "nonstandard"
19 }
20 }
21 ]
22 },
23 "error": null,
24 "id": null
25}
None of the “txid” or “hash” equals the hash I gave it at first(f4dedd64c9841d53bbda8beeda52235ec986f1400606812d9c033ac34105532c) .
- Use getrawtransaction(verbose):
0curl --user yourAuth --data-binary '{"jsonrpc": "1.0","id":"curltest","method":"getrawtransaction", "params": ["f4dedd64c9841d53bbda8beeda52235ec986f1400606812d9c033ac34105532c",true] }' -H 'content-type: text/plain;' http://yourEndPoint
This returns :
0{
1 "result": {
2 "txid": "f4dedd64c9841d53bbda8beeda52235ec986f1400606812d9c033ac34105532c",
3 "hash": "0b637b18840d8fc978a657a3422df3c246c86e4c4046d90e63bf0f86b179b403",
4 "version": 1,
5 "size": 223,
6 "vsize": 142,
7 "locktime": 0,
8 "vin": [
9 {
10 "txid": "186598dfdfb38f9423384c4e3d220f7963178e1d7c75a058cc7ceed37062a115",
11 "vout": 1,
12 "scriptSig": {
13 "asm": "",
14 "hex": ""
15 },
16 "txinwitness": [
17 "3044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb4652601",
18 "031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c4"
19 ],
20 "sequence": 4294967295
21 }
22 ],
23 "vout": [
24 {
25 "value": 0.05648959,
26 "n": 0,
27 "scriptPubKey": {
28 "asm": "OP_HASH160 2915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c OP_EQUAL",
29 "hex": "a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c87",
30 "reqSigs": 1,
31 "type": "scripthash",
32 "addresses": [
33 "35SFa5Aev3bjP7gfvfY959GSdWUrSdzoJn"
34 ]
35 }
36 },
37 {
38 "value": 11.95830840,
39 "n": 1,
40 "scriptPubKey": {
41 "asm": "0 0aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe910",
42 "hex": "00140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe910",
43 "reqSigs": 1,
44 "type": "witness_v0_keyhash",
45 "addresses": [
46 "bc1qp2ket6fjhgz9ctd0xxsycdng85u7l6gs2x4dgh"
47 ]
48 }
49 }
50 ],
51 "hex": "0100000000010115a16270d3ee7ccc58a0757c1d8e1763790f223d4e4c3823948fb3dfdf9865180100000000ffffffff023f3256000000000017a9142915a7db6c6df171fd0436c7cec0042195dad01c8738ee4647000000001600140aad95e932ba045c2daf31a04c36683d39efe91002473044022002537539ac9586fdd8b5947fa0a47dc002ebe57502608433e103efe2740f93d4022023b1ade7bdf0f002a8fdc4ec6d534588d2132ab88850ac426ea413b4adb465260121031ef964af6923a2111e4916afcc87c73a8980322cc761dd3648714dfda99e72c400000000",
52 "blockhash": "00000000000000000011ca3164ee629216de2e5dae09ffb099815319f6e35a71",
53 "confirmations": 1459,
54 "time": 1555100160,
55 "blocktime": 1555100160
56 },
57 "error": null,
58 "id": null
59}
which has the right transaction Id(txid).
They were supposed to return the same transaction,at least returns the same txid. Which result is more correct?
My node info:
0{
1 "result": {
2 "version": 170100,
3 "subversion": "/Satoshi:0.17.1/",
4 "protocolversion": 70015,
5 "localservices": "000000000000040d",
6 "localrelay": true,
7 "timeoffset": 10,
8 "networkactive": true,
9 "connections": 8,
10 "networks": [
11 {
12 "name": "ipv4",
13 "limited": false,
14 "reachable": true,
15 "proxy": "",
16 "proxy_randomize_credentials": false
17 },
18 {
19 "name": "ipv6",
20 "limited": false,
21 "reachable": true,
22 "proxy": "",
23 "proxy_randomize_credentials": false
24 },
25 {
26 "name": "onion",
27 "limited": true,
28 "reachable": false,
29 "proxy": "",
30 "proxy_randomize_credentials": false
31 }
32 ],
33 "relayfee": 0.00001000,
34 "incrementalfee": 0.00001000,
35 "localaddresses": [
36
37 ],
38 "warnings": ""
39 },
40 "error": null,
41 "id": "curltest"
42}
