Signature must be zero for failed CHECK(MULTI)SIG operation #16712

start bicoind

bitcoind -rpcuser=test -rpcpassword=test -rpcport=18443 -rpcbind=0.0.0.0 -datadir=btc_private -txindex -regtest=1 -listenonion=0 -debug -daemon

alias btccli="bitcoin-cli -regtest -rpcuser=test -rpcpassword=test"

get 3 new address

address: 2N8VaTaHNq4GPt1rbvaEAEPFwoSZ8CgDUM9
pubkey: 0355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c93
privatekey: cPZdtTsenRcKbmthFBcQB4QerVSut6Z9hMPyKo6zMeGRBGSxDGMM

address: 2N3yHeRmfNaqsR5rBVUk4fZhmfmiZswH5Rh
pubkey: 021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c
privatekey: cQxcb3foiTWKBfKT1B8fxWALzgD1SpS2QM6JcsCdFnXM5ebY5zNX

address: 2N7T4f6CAEHPyV4RfUD6NUz36AzT7J48nrz
pubkey: 033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de
privatekey: cNpLyk4X6PSyUDiJ7tPwQXRHzYPXsVCzg72g47ZW5yVyfVkmqWSt

get multisig address

btccli addmultisigaddress 2 '["2N8VaTaHNq4GPt1rbvaEAEPFwoSZ8CgDUM9","2N3yHeRmfNaqsR5rBVUk4fZhmfmiZswH5Rh","2N7T4f6CAEHPyV4RfUD6NUz36AzT7J48nrz"]'

{
  "address": "2MwabVCD88Uz7gBWyUd4mA2cXyEBMuN7w93",
  "redeemScript": "52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae"
}

btccli listunspent 1 99999999 '["2MwabVCD88Uz7gBWyUd4mA2cXyEBMuN7w93"]'

[
  {
    "txid": "66a370cb1fa86f706d3c1ff581ee80ab0c6ef69403cb09ba2eb262a27e4c0643",
    "vout": 0,
    "address": "2MwabVCD88Uz7gBWyUd4mA2cXyEBMuN7w93",
    "label": "",
    "redeemScript": "0020e4a6d84b97591a2812a4909e6cfc35429975957e674c4e92ad9054b3cca445bd",
    "witnessScript": "52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae",
    "scriptPubKey": "a9142f8a5a37a7ff99fd8671d2dcd7e62d7b4d0fd97b87",
    "amount": 50.00000000,
    "confirmations": 102,
    "spendable": true,
    "solvable": true,
    "desc": "sh(wsh(multi(2,[696a000f/0'/0'/0']0355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c93,[696a000f/0'/0'/1']021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c,[696a000f/0'/0'/2']033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de)))#3cvzvrcg",
    "safe": true
  },
  {
    "txid": "9eaa9439244b18def82abd3f85aca817126653d20add52ad2208aaa4e4f43891",
    "vout": 0,
    "address": "2MwabVCD88Uz7gBWyUd4mA2cXyEBMuN7w93",
    "label": "",
    "redeemScript": "0020e4a6d84b97591a2812a4909e6cfc35429975957e674c4e92ad9054b3cca445bd",
    "witnessScript": "52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae",
    "scriptPubKey": "a9142f8a5a37a7ff99fd8671d2dcd7e62d7b4d0fd97b87",
    "amount": 50.00000000,
    "confirmations": 101,
    "spendable": true,
    "solvable": true,
    "desc": "sh(wsh(multi(2,[696a000f/0'/0'/0']0355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c93,[696a000f/0'/0'/1']021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c,[696a000f/0'/0'/2']033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de)))#3cvzvrcg",
    "safe": true
  }
]

btccli createrawtransaction '[{"txid":"9eaa9439244b18def82abd3f85aca817126653d20add52ad2208aaa4e4f43891","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"a9142f8a5a37a7ff99fd8671d2dcd7e62d7b4d0fd97b87","redeemScript":"52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae"}]' '{"2MzycLC1fr83bHGiGhARtYbkaQ8iXoULN76":49.999}'

02000000019138f4e4a4aa0822ad52dd0ad253661217a8ac853fbd2af8de184b243994aa9e0000000000ffffffff01606b042a0100000017a91454cd00871f090949693d111080b290b18db4637e8700000000

btccli signrawtransactionwithkey '02000000019138f4e4a4aa0822ad52dd0ad253661217a8ac853fbd2af8de184b243994aa9e0000000000ffffffff01606b042a0100000017a91454cd00871f090949693d111080b290b18db4637e8700000000' '["cPZdtTsenRcKbmthFBcQB4QerVSut6Z9hMPyKo6zMeGRBGSxDGMM"]' '[{"txid":"9eaa9439244b18def82abd3f85aca817126653d20add52ad2208aaa4e4f43891","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"a9142f8a5a37a7ff99fd8671d2dcd7e62d7b4d0fd97b87","redeemScript":"52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae","amount":50}]'

{
  "hex": "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",
  "complete": false,
  "errors": [
    {
      "txid": "9eaa9439244b18def82abd3f85aca817126653d20add52ad2208aaa4e4f43891",
      "vout": 0,
      "witness": [
        "",
        "304402205ac40d5e704b78d044798e0b8b7f8bc7afb259fb5806bf0e4cb387f3d2d2dfd2022052c39670918c38cf3d5815f4d6c50af88b84614715043b3f92e4fcbce29a228201",
        "",
        "52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae"
      ],
      "scriptSig": "220020e4a6d84b97591a2812a4909e6cfc35429975957e674c4e92ad9054b3cca445bd",
      "sequence": 4294967295,
      "error": "Signature must be zero for failed CHECK(MULTI)SIG operation"
    }
  ]
}

btccli signrawtransactionwithkey '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' '["cQxcb3foiTWKBfKT1B8fxWALzgD1SpS2QM6JcsCdFnXM5ebY5zNX"]' '[{"txid":"9eaa9439244b18def82abd3f85aca817126653d20add52ad2208aaa4e4f43891","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"a9142f8a5a37a7ff99fd8671d2dcd7e62d7b4d0fd97b87","redeemScript":"52210355479b300b217d781cf058941cc1677283c24460665d27dbfced339b29428c9321021e2ef4e12c9d13fc45e709469de0ea8fe556bdbd436f13e936346f6dd267455c21033bebbfa8539df7d9b381d6bb34fabe3fc660c3c7a2f69047ac850575597ee8de53ae","amount":50}]'

{
  "hex": "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",
  "complete": true
}

btccli sendrawtransaction 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
error code: -26
error message:
non-mandatory-script-verify-flag (Signature must be zero for failed CHECK(MULTI)SIG operation) (code 64)

why i got a error like above? i need help, thanks!

Slightly related: #11891

Slightly related: #11891 but i dont see the solution of #11891 at last

I dont' think this happens any more when using descriptor wallets using the createmultisig flow. @achow101 perhaps you could confirm whether we want to keep this open any longer?

Yeah, the legacy RPCs have been removed, so this one can be closed as well.