kek-coin
commented at 9:17 am on July 5, 2017:
none
A recurring problem when helping new users getting started with running Bitcoin Core is the config file location; a lot of uncertainty is caused by the config file and the folders it should go in not being created automatically by the installation process.
It does not even have to be the full sample as found in contrib, just having an empty config file (or one with a minimal comment directing people to the sample file) created by default would ease the assisting of users on OSes one is not familiar with, as it would be easier for them to verify that they are putting their OS-agnostic configuration in the correct OS-specific location without some unnecessary trial-and-error.
laanwj added the label
Docs and Output
on Jul 5, 2017
laanwj
commented at 1:45 pm on July 5, 2017:
member
not being created automatically by the installation process.
That’s because the data directory is not known at the time of the installation process. It’s chosen on first run.
It does not even have to be the full sample as found in contrib, just having an empty config file (or one with a minimal comment directing people to the sample file) created by default
If you are using the GUI, there’s a button in the debug window to open it, also the path of the data directory can be found there.
OS-agnostic configuration in the correct OS-specific location without some unnecessary trial-and-error.
Indeed, this part is OS/distro-specific.
There is no requirement that the configuration file is writable (by the user that the daemon runs at) at all. A common setup for system-wide daemons is to put the configuration file somewhere under /etc/ and specify it using -conf. For this reason we don’t write to the configuration file from bitcoind itself, not even to create it initially.
kek-coin
commented at 4:05 pm on July 5, 2017:
none
@laanwj fair points, would an acceptable solution be to try to create the default config file (including the appropriate directories) if -conf is not set and the default config file does not exist and fail gracefully on error?
justinmoon
commented at 7:16 pm on May 13, 2018:
contributor
First time user here trying to run a full node.
Once I finally got everything working and $ bitcoind -printtoconsole started spitting out progress, I found myself wondering “What configuration am I using?”. The output included the string “Using config file /home/vagrant/.bitcoin/bitcoin.conf”. But no such file existed, which was odd.
No idea how to improve, but in my experience this was one of the more confusing parts of running daemon for the first time.
MarcoFalke added the label
good first issue
on May 13, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
6486d2b742
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
4a17fffe70
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
703c10b998
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
6928d1f582
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
2939d38fe6
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
04be012da9
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
a517c47665
on Jul 26, 2018
leishman referenced this in commit
08def4b624
on Jul 26, 2018
cisba
commented at 4:45 pm on September 7, 2018:
contributor
As pointed by @laanwj “…the data directory is not known at the time of the installation process. It’s chosen on first run”.
But isn’t this feature the origin of problems? Isn’t that a choice to be moved in the packages setup process?
If the answer would be yes, then the setup could put also the bitcoin.conf file in the right place.
MarcoFalke
commented at 5:09 pm on September 7, 2018:
member
leishman
commented at 9:32 pm on September 9, 2018:
contributor
@MarcoFalke yes, #14057 is the simplest solution to this problem. Creating the default conf file is a bit more complex and will probably have to be merged later.
jarolrod
commented at 4:53 am on March 10, 2021:
member
Why not just instruct someone to cp the example bitcoin.conf under bitcoin/share/examples/ into their data directory. This can be included in the docs somewhere in the appropriate place. Something like the following:
If you would like to configure your bitcoin node, an example bitcoin.conf including all possible configuration options is provided. Copy this example into your data directory.
You can now open up the copied file with your favorite text editor and uncomment the options that fit your needs.
laanwj
commented at 7:23 am on March 15, 2021:
member
I like your suggestion @jarolrod . Having a documented example configuration could be useful. But it would not be good to have another separate source of truth for the option help (more maintenance work, creates a merge “hotspot”, documentations can diverge over time). Could it be generated from the --help on make install?
josibake
commented at 10:59 am on June 11, 2021:
member
@laanwj seems like it would be possible to generate from --help using something like the following:
0bitcoind -h | sed -E "s/^[[:space:]]{2}\-/#/" | sed -E "s/^[[:space:]]{7}/# /" | sed '/[=[:space:]]/!s/#.*$/&=1/' > /path/to/example/bitcoin.conf
not 100% there (remove a few options like version, conf and add some text that explains it is a config file), but does this seem like a feasible approach? if so, i can finish the sed expression.
also, im not super familiar with make and wasn’t sure where to add this expression so that it gets run during make install. any pointers?
josibake referenced this in commit
b624755f49
on Jun 17, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
60fb568ec0
on Jun 18, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
9df03cb5c5
on Aug 9, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
e128fc9add
on Aug 10, 2021
chrisbward
commented at 9:57 pm on October 7, 2021:
none
This isn’t great. It’s just caught me out.
What’s the most basic conf to get going?
I’m doing everything over cli, so I’m totally in the dark here
chrisbward
commented at 10:20 pm on October 7, 2021:
none
What’s the most basic conf file I could need? At least someone post that please…. I’m on 22
josibake referenced this in commit
e7b89a3037
on Oct 19, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
6bb5004123
on Dec 22, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
f8902efcb1
on Dec 22, 2021
josibake referenced this in commit
b6951c09d0
on Dec 27, 2021
ghost
commented at 3:17 am on December 28, 2021:
none
Or check different options and create a config file based on your needs
josibake referenced this in commit
e7b3d75022
on Dec 28, 2021
niVelion
commented at 1:22 pm on January 12, 2022:
none
Since @MarcoFalke added the “good first issue” label to this issue @josibake and @prayank23 have proposed PRs, I think this label could at least for now be removed - I’m not sure this is the best starting point anymore.
MarcoFalke
commented at 1:27 pm on January 12, 2022:
member
“Good first issue” also means that this might be a good starting point to review. Instead of looking for “good first issue” to create a pull request, one can also look for “good first issue” to find existing pull requests to review.
josibake referenced this in commit
24fa77492d
on Jan 12, 2022
josibake referenced this in commit
dbaa3e5498
on Jan 12, 2022
josibake referenced this in commit
53826de216
on Jan 12, 2022
gargabhishek100
commented at 8:51 am on January 25, 2022:
none
Is this issue is still open?
Is anything there to help into?
ghost
commented at 9:26 am on January 25, 2022:
none
Is this issue is still open? Is anything there to help into?
This is a metadata mirror of the GitHub repository
bitcoin/bitcoin.
This site is not affiliated with GitHub.
Content is generated from a GitHub metadata backup.
generated: 2024-11-17 09:12 UTC
This site is hosted by @0xB10C More mirrored repositories can be found on mirror.b10c.me
